SEN 2865 Where are you on the altimeter field?
- Category: Archive 2021
- Hits: 140
Where are you on the altimeter field?
1. Question for Allard
2. Altimeters and beyond
3. On flying 1km upwind
4. Where was the F1X on the field?
Question for Allard
From: Ed skorepa
Obviously, timer keeper will have to verify that altimeter reads ZERO m with an airplane placed on the ground just before the launch. How will they do that?
Editor’s comment. I understand that the way the altimeter works is that it detects the moment of launch and uses the altitude it measures at that point as the base. The readings are then taken relative to the point. Also the device has a green LED that show any previous reading that has been cleared that the time keeper can check. Allard can confirm this.
Altimeters and beyond
Thank you Stuart for having summarized in a few, excellent sentences the problem(s) and motivations we have to tackle.
Talking as an elder modeller, I remember the day I decided to do FreeFlight because it was different from other sports, it was full circle and you had to deal with BOM rule, aerodynamic, meteorology, construction and many more. Not just (bought) javelin throwing!
On the other side Allard reminds us to consider seriously the duty’s we face because other’s like to use the airspace we considered “ours”. In addition, they like to use airspace for commercial purposes and as always, it is hard to argue against money. Probably on the base of these restrictions, altimeters and GPS will be included in the FF models of tomorrow.
However, that does not yet mean they have to be used for the essential part of the competition, the timing. They may help not violating the legal boundaries. Nevertheless, timing should remain as is with all the shortcomings included. As Pierre writes, otherwise we have to rewrite a complete new set of rules.
On my part, to preserve the “sportsman”, I will follow the original dream of a sport in which results origins from my personal work and not from my wallet or other.
On flying 1km upwind
From:Allard van Wallene
Some of the arguments against the use of altimetry tend to the conviction of free flight being a luck game where bad luck is just part of the equation we have to (must?) live with.
An inexperienced near sighted time keeper assigned to you without bino’s.
Your model flying behind a tree line while others don’t.
Your model flying into the only downdraft on the field.
Your model DT’ing early because your clockwork timer decided to run fast or not DT-ing at all.
So if this luck game aspect is so important to these sportsmen, then why did they change to e-timers? Why do they invest in thermal reading equipment? Why did they buy binoculars, GPS, trackers?
I see some of the arguments as resisting technological progress just for the sake of it, and we must stick to the old nostalgia. Remember a similar discussion on radio DT in the nineties? Still of the opinion this is bad?
If the sheer joy of bad luck is so important to them, then why don’t they drop all the above tools from their tool box and go back to the old Seelig timers or fuse?
Or drop the F1 class altogether and start nostalgia?
If one model flies downwind to a spot 50 meters lower and the other flying upwind 50 meters higher. This is free flight. One flies longer than the other. A time keeper will record this, just like an altimeter will show this. The presence of an altimeter in the fuselage won’t change the flight behaviour of the model.
If a model flies out of sight for a time keeper, this is the bad luck (or ‘joy’ for some) of free flight. This is a however a subjective opinion.
If an altimeter shows the model flew into a 50 meter deep valley and continued flying for a higher scoring out of the time keeper’s sight, this would be just as much good luck und just as much joy of free flight as staying within eye sight of a time keeper. Just another subjective opinion.
The final result will however be objective.
Thermals and good luck to all!
Where was the F1X on the field?
Answer to Giorgio Venuti. It makes no difference what the topography of the terrain is. An altimeter records the height above some fixed datum - sometimes Sea Level, but more often from the point of departure. Even if the models are launched from points of differing altitude the altimeter will determine the height from the point of launch, thus eliminating any such perceived advantage.
This is SEN, short for SouthernCaliforniaAeroTeam Electronic News. The SouthernCaliforniaAeroTeam is a model airplane club that is dedicated to FAI class free flight model airplanes and so is this electronic newsletter and its emphasis.
It is published on a frequent but irregular basis. There is no charge for getting it. It is emailed to you and an archive is kept online at www.faifreeflight.org .
We welcome contributions from all our readers about all aspects of FAI free flight model airplanes. Contributions include, notices of upcoming events, results , individual items for sale, information about new product and services of interest to our readers, suggestions about rules changes, discussions or comments on new technologies. Over 1000 people read each issue and they are in about 40 countries world wide.
We do not publish pictures or plans , although you can include links to them. Ideally material for inclusion should be formatted fairly simply. An article with complex formatting is more likely to get messed up when included in SEN. Results of contests should be submitted in a Microsoft Excel file.
Remember that for many of the readers English is a second language. Also it most important to exchange information so sometimes there will be errors of spelling or grammar, this is not a problem and we are more interested the ideas and information rather than how it is written.
While the main interest of SEN is FAI class free flight we publish items of information about of classes of free flight and subjects that we think will be of interest to our readers. An important aspect of FAI Free Flight is innovation and new ideas so looking at what people are doing in other branches of our hobby/sport is always a good idea. Recently some people have complained about us including reference to non FAI events, we appreciate that our hobby is very diverse so we use editorial judgment that this information is of interest to some of our readers.
Preparing SEN is a lot of work and it is made easier by us just cutting and pasting the information that you send. If you make a mistake and need to correct something be sure to resend us the entire corrected item and we will republish it in the next issue. Never just send fixes to the incorrect article and ask us to make it right, we don't know what you think is right, you have to do that. Similarly if an article you wrote got messed when included in SEN you are welcome to reformat it it more simply and we will include the re-structured piece in the next issue. If you have sent several versions of an article and you think we published the wrong one, do not ask us to publish the right one, just sent it us again.
If you are selling an item, be sure to tell people how to get in touch with you. It is a good idea to say what city and country you live in. Remember we will print the Advertisement as you write it, we are not you ad copy writer.
As a general matter of course we publish the name of the person who wrote the article. There are very few people, one less since the death of Martyn Cowley aka Biggles, when we use a nom de plume. Typically unattributed articles are written by the editorial staff.
We use a service provider to manage the server used to host our web site and mailing engine. The mail service provider requires each person enters, maintains and confirms their email mailing list. There is a link at the end of each SEN that lets you unsubscribe and modify your subscription details, like the email address. Sometimes SEN may get treated as spam by you email provider and it will eventually automatically unsubscribed. If this happens you can go to the link at the end of the SEN mailing and re-subscribe yourself. Similarly if you unsubscribe your self by accident you fix it by using the link. These links at the end are tied to your SEN Subscription so don’t forward your copy to anyone else as it lets them potentially modify you subscription BUT there is another URL there that will send a copy to a friend.