SCAT Electronic News 2 August 1999
- Details
- Category: Archive 1999
- Hits: 1111
SCAT Electronic News 2 August 1999
Table of Contents
==================
Comment on Bob Perkins Mulvihill proposal - Jahnke
Proposed Mulvihill Rules Change - Murphy
Russian Cup Event ABC
Comment on Bob Perkins Mulvihill proposal
=========================================
Author : This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Roger,
I would like to comment on Bob Perkins Mulvihill proposal. Three caveats
about my comments: I don't currently fly the event, I fly F1B, F1G and P-30;
I worked closely with Bob on the 1999 sympo and have learned to respect his
judgement on modeling matters; I didn't receive a complete set of comments
in the Scat News.
1. In my opinion, if there is any event suffering from excess performance
Mulvihill is it. Evidence of this is in contest scores and in the very slow
evolution of the model itself. Very old designs are competative with only
minor changes in airfoil, prop hub (usually a teeny-torque) and propeller
blade design.
2. The reasons for excess performance stated above are the reasons I think
many mulvihill fliers like the event.
3. Bob's proposal will lead some modelers to higher aspect ratio wings,
which will lead to composite materials, etc. which will lead to grumbling by
others.
4. Not all category III sites will tolerate the longer maxes. The sites I
fly on in Pensacola will barely tolerate a mid day max of 3 minutes, let
alone 4.
5. If Mulvihill is to progress Bob's proposed change is necessary. The
question is whether Mulvihill participants really want progress.
Proposed Mulvihill Rules Change
===============================
Jerry Murphy AMA 917
Dist IX FFCB member
The proposal for increased maximum flight times for Mulvihill is an
interesting attempt to decrease the number of flyoff flights. I,
however fail to see the logic behind the increased flight times for
flights two and three. If the field is a Cat II or III site it is
usually because it won't support longer flights. So why start out at
two or three minutes and then increase the max. It might make more
sense to reverse the order as the wind usually increases during the
day.
The MMM filed in Denver is a very large site, but it doesn't lend its
self to five minute maxs as the chase will be very long and the
chances of a lost model are greatly increased.
If this proposal is to be made, it MUST be flown in real live
competition first. Make it so at the Muncie site and see what
happens. Fly it for at least five contests and then see if the
proposal works before we are stuck with a bad untested rule in the
book.
My feeling is no testing = a no vote.
Thermals,
Murph
Russian Cup Event ABC
=====================
Author : This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
Dear Roger.
I send you the results of the Russian Open National Championship 1999,
World Cup event in F1A, F1B, F1C free flight models, Orel, Russia, 23-25
of July.
It was a great contest, weather was perfect. We started the first round
at 6 am, except F-1-C (9 am, it was a fog) and flyoff at 6-30 pm. It was
a sunny and 25 gr. C temperature, wind was 1-3 m per sec. for F1A and
F1B and till 5 m per sec. for F1C.
Sincerely, Sergei Makarov.
F-1-A Orel, Russia 23 of July’99
1 Pankov Sergey Russia 1290+300+420+251
2 Zastashkov Alexandre Russia 1290+300+420+203
3 Arepyev Kirill Russia 1290+262
4 Kochkarev Mikhail Russia 1290+244
5 Riazantsev Alexey Russia 1290+217
6 Russky Pavel Russia 1290+201
7 Titov Yuri Russia 1290+199
8 Slotin Igor Russia 1290+195
9 Lisovik Anatoly Ukraine 1290+188
9 Khoroshev Pavel Russia 1290+188
11 Diadechko Oleg Russia 1290+184
12 Maslovsky Anatoly Russia 1290+169
13 Pushkov Andrey Russia 1290+136
14 Kozlov Igor Russia 1284
15 Isaenko Viktor Ukraine 1279
16 Bardin Vladimir Russia 1278
17 Bezukladnikov Andrey Russia 1273
18 Anokhin Leonid Russia 1269
19 Romanov Alexey Russia 1264
20 Makarov Sergey Russia 1252
21 Drobishev Vladimir Russia 1248
22 Egorov Dmitry Russia 1237
23 Anufriev A. Russia 1234
24 Ribin Gennady Russia 1233
25 Samsonov Alexey Russia 1232
26 Khodunov S. Russia 1229
27 Latishev Alexandre Russia 1222
28 Kovalenko Sergey Ukraine 1217
29 Kalutsky Alexandre Russia 1212
30 Serebrjakov Sergey Russia 1207
31 Stshagin Mikhail Russia 1195
32 Katin A. Russia 1187
33 Grisjuk Maxim Russia 1181
34 Shershyunov Anatoly Russia 1179
35 Krokhin Yuri Russia 1171
36 Poliaev Valery Russia 1170
37 Stsherbakov Mikhail Russia 1155
38 Andrjushin Sergey Russia 1153
39 Aliakbarov Elton Russia 1149
40 Sankin Evgeny Russia 1145
41 Evdokimov Yuri Russia 1133
42 Mitkov Alexandre Russia 1132
43 Anisimov N. Russia 1129
44 Startsev A. Russia 1127
45 Razumovsky Dmitry Russia 1124
46 Gilfanov Almaz Russia 11214
46 Tikhonov Alexandre Russia 11214
48 Lipin Andrey Russia 1104
49 Zakharov Alexey Russia 1095
50 Shumov Alexey Russia 1084
51 Chesnokov Andrey Russia 1072
52 Zhuravliov Alexey Russia 1041
53 Grigorash Anatoly Russia 1040
54 Larionov Anton Russia 1036
55 Lobanov Igor Russia 1032
56 Mkrtchjan Harry Russia 1030
57 Radko Alexandre Russia 1023
58 Korshunov Sergey Russia 1008
59 Semenov Vladimir Russia 982
59 Skripachev Vladimir Russia 982
61 Grachov Andrey Russia 979
62 Mikenin Alexey Russia 959
63 Teriokhin Gennady Russia 947
64 Kozirev Sergey Russia 939
65 Gusev Sergey Russia 876
66 Aksenov Maxim Russia 845
67 Posipanova Svetlana Russia 844
68 Nesterenko Alexey Russia 832
69 Karpov Sergey Russia 821
70 Lisov Ivan Russia 608
71 Fedorov Denis Russia 291
F-1-C Orel, Russia, 25 of July'99
1 Mikhajlenko Alexandre Russia 1318
2 Trofimov Alexandre Russia 1309
3 Galaktionov Leonid Russia 1306
4 Makhovikh Vladimir Russia 1283
5 Fuzeyev Leonid Russia 1237
6 Chuchukalov Leonid Russia 1233
7 Kharitonov Mikhail Russia 1213
8 Aminov Maxim Russia 1209
9 Onufrienko Viktor Russia 1202
10 Kobozev Igor Russia 1194
11 Korban Sergey Russia 1192
12 Toloknov Andrey Russia 1182
13 Rakhmankin Sergey Russia 1177
14 Ivanov Vladimir I. Russia 1171
15 Rjokhin Nikolay Russia 1161
16 Targamadze Revaz Russia 1143
17 Kontorovich Alexandre Russia 1131
18 Summersby Roy Australia 1080
19 Morshinin Evgeny Russia 1058
20 Drozdov Alexandre Russia 1051
21 Naumenko Andrey Russia 1027
22 Shurigin Mikhail Russia 985
23 Ribalko Nikolay Russia 935
24 Krivoshein Vladimir Russia 790
25 Korobko Mikhail Russia 728
26 Djukarev Vladimir Russia 607
27 Tikhonenko Alexandre Russia 600
28 Morozov Alexandre Russia 468
29 Tsiruljov Mikhail Russia 453
F-1-B Orel, Russia, 24 of July'99
1 Bondarenko Igor Russia 1290+300+367
2 Fedorov Vladimir Russia 1290+300+346
3 Burdov Andrey Russia 1290+300+315
4 Vasis Sergey Russia 1290+300+310
5 Shagun Alexandre Ukraine 1290+300+296
6 Gorbach Grigory Russia 1290+300+288
7 Khuziev Radik Russia 1290+300+286
8 Shelepov Alexandre Russia 1290+300+270
9 Beljaev Alexandre Russia 1290+300+211
10 Rogov Vasily Russia 1290+300+196
11 Pushkarev Dmitry Russia 1290+300+175
12 Mushtukov Valentin Russia 1290+299
13 Khrebtov Andrey Russia 1290+275
14 Elbakidze Yury Russia 1290+260
15 Mustafin Julay Russia 1290+257
16 Vivchar Igor Ukraine 1290+245
17 Kislovsky Anton Russia 1290+244
18 Mikheyev Nikolay Russia 1290+242
19 Solodov Maxim Russia 1290+242
20 Filippov Alexey Russia 1290+239
21 Naumov Alexey Russia 1290+235
22 Chanchikov Konstantin Russia 1290+228
23 Mironenko Vladimir Russia 1290+203
24 Korobko Mikhail Russia 1290+194
25 Komarov Vladimir Russia 1290+190
26 Novikov Alexandre K. Russia 1276
27 Rodionov Andrey Russia 1271
28 Ivanov Valery Russia 1268
29 Il'in Sergey Russia 1265
30 Savin Konstantin Russia 1255
31 Novikov Viktor Russia 1253
32 Ignat'ev Vadim Russia 1248
33 Kurovtsev Igor Russia 1246
34 Makarov Alexandre Russia 1238
35 Pakulin Mikhail Russia 1238
36 Shebalkov Alexandre Russia 1238
37 Lestchov Matvey Russia 1234
38 Lomov Sergey Russia 1234
39 Sisoev Vitaly Russia 1233
40 Kuzin Dmitry Russia 1232
41 Kolobjanin Vadim Russia 1230
42 Gainibasharov Vladimir Russia 1220
43 Makhijanov Alexandre Russia 1217
44 Manyshev Vladimir Russia 1209
45 Samokhin Vitaly Russia 1177
46 Smirnov Viktor Russia 1171
47 Egorov Yury Russia 1165
48 Geraskin Pavel Russia 1162
49 Sharaborin Vladimir Russia 1150
50 Shelepov Alexey Russia 1142
51 Idlov Dmitry Russia 1136
52 Romanovsky Valerian Russia 1132
53 Grushichev Alexandre Russia 1125
54 Korolev Sergey Russia 1094
55 Gatijatullin Ruslan Russia 1056
56 Trokhimik Alexandre Russia 991
57 Kuptsov Sergey Russia 975
58 Serebrjakov Denis Russia 970
59 Larin Alexandre Russia 962
60 Nazarov Alexandre Russia 894
61 Petukhov Ivan Russia 892
62 Chikovsky Dmitry Russia 878
63 Serdjuk Alexandre Russia 706
64 Jashin Dmitry Russia 542
65 Khobotov Sergey Russia 273
66 Nikitin Sergey Russia 260
67 Stepanov Mikhail Russia 190
68 Jakovlev Andrey Russia 142
.............
Roger Morrell
